Have an issue with your insurance?
Let everyone know!
Insurance companies are constantly reviewing us. Are we too old? Do we live in the wrong place? Is our credit score high enough? Well, now it's time to turn the tables. Do you charge too much? Will you pay my claim quickly? Is your coverage worse than it seems? We can review you too.
Recent Reviews
Medicare - Health insurance
I have met my Medicare deductible. I have plan G Medicare supplement which pays all co-pays, etc.
I am being billed by a doctor’s office in spite of the fact that I have no further liability for co-pays. What is the best way to resolve this as the doctors office keep sending me a bill.
Hagerty - Hagerty / Specialty Car Insurance _ Audi B5 S4
I've had a Hagerty policy for about 4 years on my B5 S4. For context, I live on Long Island, NY. Around December of last year I made a decision to remove the insurance and plates from the vehicle due to other priorities in life. Over the years, my annual policy rate typically ranged between $600 to $720 with an agreed upon value of $15k. Deductibles were $500 and property damage / bodily injury was set to $100k/300k with supplemental at $50k.
The time has come to get insurance and plates for the car, again. I got a quote from Hagerty yesterday and it came up to $2370 per year! The policy was configured identically to the last quote I received for renewal in February of 2025 which was quoted at $719 for the year. My driving record, credit score and address is the same.
I called up to have someone review and validate that I have configured the quote criteria exactly as the recently canceled policy. The Hagerty rep confirmed the policy configuration and was also shocked by the difference in the quote. She mentioned that there was an increase recently to all NY issued policies but she did not have any other value added info.
Do any of you fellow redditors have a recommendation for a specialty vehicle policy with other companies? I filled out an additional application with Grundy that is currently under review.
GEICO - Incredibly petty question about pedestrian (me) vehicle crash FL.
I'm probably going include an annoying amount of detail, so feel free to skip to the tl/dr.
A little more than a week ago, I was struck by a car while riding my bike on a sidewalk (legal in my area). The driver was turning right and only checked to his left. I slowed and thought he saw me (FL allows DARK tint). I was wrong. He impacted my tire and my knee only stopping when I stuck his passenger window with my fist.
My first words were "did you even fucking look?" at volume 24. That prompted a "calm down lady". I saw red about the same time that I noticed his EMT cadet uniform.
The officer who responded didn't ticket him. But the crash report is clear that he is at fault. The officer asked if I would be willing to allow the driver to pay out of pocket if the damage was property only. I'm not a monster wanting to throw barrels into the path of this young man's life so I had the wheel repaired and ignored the minor cosmetic stuff.
I texted him the $33 bill from my very reasonable bike guy. He swore he would send a check. (I do not want him having access to more information than he currently has). Well guess what? Yeah.
I'm just done. I want to make a claim on the policy on the police report. But it's GEICO, which us also my own insurance policy. Will the pidling petty little claim red flag me to my own carrier?
Tl/dr Emt cadet hit me with a car. Got very lucky with a tiny amount of damage. Will Geico ding me if I file a claim since he failed to self pay?
my insurance company - Rear ended by uninsured driver/Diminution of Value
I was rear ended by a driver with an out of state license, but his truck is registered in this state (Texas), he seemed to be a shady individual as well to me when dealing with him.
The police came and wrote a report but it didn’t technically put him at fault even though he rear ended me. I did however get him on video admitting he was at fault. I filed the claim with his insurance, but it was a slow response from them. I went ahead and filed with mine to get the ball rolling because I needed to get it fixed. Well turns out that was a good move because come to find out he wasn’t covered by his insurance company at the time. So basically he got away with having no insurance when the police arrived because he had a paper saying he did.
My question is now that my truck is fixed and back to normal, I received a diminution in value evaluation form from my insurance company for me to fill out. Is this to provide a compensation due to my truck now losing some value to the accident? It had never been in an accident previously so what can I expect towards compensation based on the value of the truck. Its KBB value ranges from $15-$19k. It’s in excellent condition though. How would diminution work according to that? Will my insurance company send me a check or something?
Also on a side note, can I contact the police to inform them that his insurance company called me and said that he was not covered at the time? Could they pursue a ticket to him even though he has an out of state license?
insurance company - Insurance estimate is different from the contractor estimate
A couple of weeks ago a gentleman ran the stop sign in front of my house and used my new mudroom as a stopping mechanism. We were told to get an estimate from a contractor and they would cut us a check. We got a detailed estimate and the insurance company sent it out for review. The review came back with a 6000.00$ reduction in the estimate due to not enough detail on the labor side of the estimate. The insurance agent said that we could accept the money while we submitted an updated more detailed estimate to get the extra 6000.00$. Should we take the money while we wait for the contractor to update the estimate or should we get the updated estimate first?
Hanover - Screwed by Hanover on a collision claim. What are my options?
In May, I rearended another vehicle. My fault, I'm a dumbass. The damage was to my left front bumper, which was pushed back into the tire, the left front fender, and left headlamp. At the scene, the truck was not drivable due to the bumper being pushed into the tire, so I called a tow truck. The tow driver showed up and offered that rather than towing, he could hook his winch to the front bumper and pull it out to make the truck drivable again. I was good with that plan and it saved money for the insurance company on the tow bill. A couple days later, I take the truck to the insurance company's DRP shop. I told them all of the above.
A couple weeks go by, I go to pick the truck up. They fixed everything EXCEPT the left fender, saying that the damage was unrelated due to a "soft impact". No one from the insurance company ever called to discuss. In reality, the fender looked dented in from partial reformation when the bumper was winched out. But again, no one ever called for the partial denial of damages and just left it to the body shop to tell me.
So I filed a DOI complaint citing the lack of investigation by the adjuster. The DOI rep never called me but closed the case, stating that the insurance company did nothing wrong. The DOI letter cited the appraisal clause in the policy, however, at this point I'm more angry about the lack of communication and investigation by the adjuster as it was very shoddy and incomplete work. I also don't think hiring an appraiser would be particularly effective in arguing related damages (but maybe I'm wrong?). I don't think I'm able to sue over damages due to the appraisa clause in the policy but would prefer to sue for bad faith. Or maybe I should just walk away and pay to have my fender repaired? Anyone have experience here or ideas on what I should do?
Porsche - Need help in understanding.
I purchased a brand-new 2023 Porsche Macan S for $82,000. After taxes, the total came to $86,000. I also purchased all available extended warranties and protection plans through Porsche, covering the engine, transmission, wheel/tire protection, paint/weather discoloration, etc., bringing the total investment to approximately $102,000.
As of 2025, the car has only 14,000 miles, mostly from commuting to and from work. The vehicle was in excellent condition with no engine damage.
Recently, I was involved in a collision accident, and the fault was determined to be entirely on the other party. Unfortunately, my insurance company has declared the car a total loss because the repair cost is around $40,000, and the vehicle would receive a salvage title, thereby reducing its market value significantly. My insurer has offered me $72,000 as the settlement.
This situation leaves me $30,000 short of what I initially paid, even without factoring in the warranty and extras.
🟦 1. Can I still negotiate with the insurance company after they totaled my car?
🟦 2. Should I buy back the totaled car and fix it?
🟦 3. I had 5-year warranties — if the car is totaled after 2 years, will I get refunded for the remaining 3 years?
Thank you to anyone who sees this message and replies back.
AllState - Additionally Insured Renters
I recently signed a lease for a new apartment. I currently have AllState, however they don’t allow Landlords/businesses to be additionally insured under my policy.
So what insurances do allow landlords to be additionally insured? NOT an additional interest. I can’t find any information on this! And every customer support/agent I talk to gets very confused.
GEICO - GEICO to GEICO insurance claim issue
On July 24, I was involved in an accident in Houston, where the other car suddenly changed lanes on the highway and caused an accident. I called the police and the other driver accepted his fault. Police has made a incident report and seems like full report takes some time to come. We both had geico insurance. Police made the incident report and gave me the details of the other person's details, insurance policy and all but did ask me for anything. Now, when I call geico, they say that they have not yet gotten the other person's statement. I don't know what my options are. They also did not respond to my rental car issue and i had to get it myself. I missed couple of day of work as well due to the body pain. What should I do?
The other driver's insurance - Drunk driver hit my parked truck — now I’m missing work and rental coverage is being denied. What can I do?
Last Sunday, I was having dinner with family when a drunk driver left the restaurant parking lot and decided to take my parked truck with him. Thankfully, nobody was in the vehicle, but the damage was significant — around $6,000 according to the repair shop.
The other driver's insurance accepted liability and is covering the damages to my truck, which is good. But here’s where it gets frustrating.
I live alone in a rural area and have no other transportation. I work weekend shifts (Friday–Sunday) with regular overtime (usually two extra 12-hour days). Because I had no vehicle, I missed work this weekend. The truck was towed to the shop, but they can’t begin repairs until *two Mondays from now*.
The insurance company told me they won’t cover a rental car until repairs actually begin, even though their policyholder was 100% at fault and drunk. How is that fair? I'm out two weeks of transportation and potentially $1,800 in lost wages because of this.
I’ve never filed a claim before, and I feel totally lost in this process. Some questions:
1. Can I push the insurance company to cover a rental now, not just when repairs start?
2. Is there a way to claim lost wages due to this incident? I have no PTO, and this is directly affecting my livelihood.
3. Should I be speaking to an attorney about this, or is there another route to escalate the claim?
Any advice or guidance would be really appreciated.
Update- I live in Maine but the accident happened in new Hampshire if that makes a difference.
Make A Complaint
Loading...